8 votes
Count the number of feedbacks given by the CH in main forum.
Currently, the site only counts the number of feedbacks given by the CH on the designers page instead of the main forum. I thought the purpose of giving feedback to one designer was to also allow the other designers to see what direction the CH wants to go. Why not have that feedback on one page instead of having designers dig into other designers page to see the CH feedback. If the CH references a particular design (ie #4), that should count towards giving designer feedback under the "Health" and also when viewing the list of contests being held by the CH.
snugbrimm
i agree that their discussion board posts should be considered too because i see alot of unhealthy contests where all the feedback is just on the discussion board. I think they were also having problems figuring out how to even give feedback individually but with the new "click to leave feedback" that won't be as big of a problem
7 months ago
paulgrimshaw
Hi, just a quick note - I started doing comments on each page but it is much easier doing it all in one go. a better way may be to use the 'next designer' part but only show pages with designs still in contention...
7 months ago
Nadia
Yes it should I agree, but the contest holder should always make the feedback on the individual designers' page.... how to get them to do that is another issue :-)
Maybe the backend is too difficult for them, or they don't realise they can go to the individual page (not sure how all that works).... or there is too much going backwards and forwards and they can't be bothered.... don't know
8 months ago
Rodney
I like the current system of having all the comments for a specific designer on a separate page. It helps keep things organized.
I do agree that if a design does get referenced by the contest holder on the main contest for by number, that it should count towards the "health" of the contest.
8 months ago